In the geo-political chess game that took place in the post-World War I world, the two main ethnic groups in the of Fiume/Rijeka (Italians/Croats) were pawns used to advance the interests of Italy and Yugoslavia. This was especially true of the former as Fiume became intertwined with the rise of fascism in Italy. The situation would take several years to sort out. In another one of those post-World War One concoctions which lead to strife rather than peace, the peacemakers attempted to impose a settlement with the Treaty of Rapallo. This put an end to Gabrielle D’Annunzio’s so called Italian Regency of Canaro and led to the creation of the Free State of Fiume, an autonomous entity. It would take several more years and yet another agreement – the Treaty of Rome – to put an end to the free state’s survival as Italian Fascism ensured that Fiume would become part of the Kingdom of Italy.
A Temporary Settlement – The Free State of Fiume
The arrangement imposed upon Fiume/Rijeka was contentious. Italy and Yugoslavia were to share the city. This was a sort of precursor to the East Berlin/West Berlin where the border between the two ran through the city. The border was not a new one, rather it restored an older one known as the “Corpus separatum” which had been in existence prior to World War I. This division had been between a Hungarian administered section and one ruled by Croatians. The border used an existing natural feature. Known by the less than appealing name as “the dead channel”, it was a former channel of the Rijecine River. The river had been diverted upstream from the channel for flood control, thus it was dead. Unfortunately, “the dead channel” was alive with consternation when a new border between the Italian and Yugoslav (Croat) parts of Fiume/Rijeka was imposed upon it. A wall was also erected to better define the border between the two sides.
Fiume/Rijeka was supposed to be a relatively autonomous free city. Instead, it became a divided city with the urban core under Italian administration and the Susak district falling under Yugoslav rule. Separation and segregation led to many hard feelings. These exploded into violence during the Second World War. By then D’Annunzio’s 1919 occupation of the city was a distant memory. He had long since been trumped by Benito Mussolini, but the Italian foothold in Rijeka could not last any longer than fascism. The Yugoslavs would not tolerate Italian communities on land they now controlled. Rijeka became a Yugoslav city through and through. It would later become part of Croatia when Yugoslavia imploded. Today, Rijeka is the third largest city in Croatia with an economically vibrant port. The Italian claims on Fiume/Rijeka belong to another era. One, like the ethnic Italian population of the city, that no longer exists.
Users & Losers – The Fate of Fiume
After Tito ascended to the helm of Yugoslav leadership there was only one place the Italians of Fiume could go and that was anywhere but home. Home was no longer Fiume. That city no longer existed, at least from a geopolitical standpoint. It is often said that the winner’s write history and they changed Fiume to Rijeka. This meant that ethnic Italians would have to return to a place many of them had never really been, the nation of Italy. While Fiume had been part of Italy from 1920 – 1944, it was never really part of Italy the way such cities as Rome, Florence or Naples were. It was on the periphery, an appendage that the fascists connected to Italy. The tether between Fiume and the Italian was always fragile. With Italy on its knees after World War II, there was nowhere for Fiume to go, but back to Yugoslavia.
For ethnic Italians who were either fleeing or forced to leave Fiume, going back to Italy could have been a safety valve. It was nothing of the sort. They were welcomed with anger by countrymen who considered them less Italian. The newcomers were competitors for scarce resources, namely jobs in an economy that was still in dire straits. This led to rioting. Nonetheless, for those Italians exiled from Fiume there was no going back. Tito’s Yugoslavia would never welcome back Italians. The only welcome they would have gotten was at a prison camp. Thus, they had no choice but stay in Italy. Fiume under Italian control had been a short lived thing, at least in an official sense. It had lasted little more than a generation. Of course, Italians had been the commercial class for much longer than that. The Republic of Venice and Austria-Hungary had always found them useful. And the Italians of Fiume allowed themselves to be used. It was in their best interest to do so until one day it was not. That day would not come until after Venice and Austria-Hungary has passed into history. Oddly enough, D’Annunzio, the prototypical nationalist Italian, had used those in Fiume for his personal rather than imperial interests. In the process he set them up ultimately for failure. And the Italians of Fiume were complicit in their own demise. World War II took care of the rest.
The Historian – You Can Never Leave Home
Fiume is no more, but its effect on Croatia and Italy has been lasting. Due to the failure of fascist Italy, Yugoslavia and later Croatia became the recipients of an excellent commercial port. The Yugoslavs and Croats needed the port much more than Italy ever did. It has served them well. As for Fiume’s Italian legacy, it is due to one of those unintended consequences that makes history so deliciously ironic. The man who reputedly gave the order that Benito Mussolini be killed at war’s end was Leo Valiani who was born in Fiume. Valiani’s ethnic background is representative of the tapestry of ethnicities that once called the city home. Valiani was the son of a Hungarian Jewish couple. He later became an Italian citizen.
An anti-fascist to the core, he received a five year sentence for his political activities. Up until the outbreak of World War II, Valiani had been a committed communist before becoming disenchanted with Stalin’s treatment of Poland. He eventually found his way into the Italian resistance where he became a leader. Valiani not only signed off on Mussolini’s death warrant, he also would become the primary author of Italy’s constitution. Perhaps as an outsider, the Fiume born, Jewish Valiani could objectively scrutinize and understand Italians better than most. He was certainly shaped by what had happened in his birthplace. Valiani’s life occupation was not as a politician, but as an historian. And Fiume is nothing, if not history.